Snohomish County

Washington Supreme Court will hear Edmonds property owner's dogwood tree case

The Washington Supreme Court agreed Nov. 6 to review an appeals ruling that ended an Edmonds man's damages claim over a tree condition on his home permit.

The Temple of Justice in Olympia, where the Washington Supreme Court will hear the Edmonds tree permit case, March 24, 2012
The Temple of Justice in Olympia, where the Washington Supreme Court will hear the Edmonds tree permit case, March 24, 2012. Photo: Harvey Barrison / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0 . Cropped and resized.

Hero photo: The Temple of Justice in Olympia, home of the Washington Supreme Court, which will hear the Edmonds dogwood tree permit case, photographed March 24, 2012, by Harvey Barrison via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0. Cropped and resized.

Key Takeaways

  • The Washington Supreme Court on Nov. 6 granted review in Rimmer v. City of Edmonds, a dispute over a tree condition that held up an Edmonds man's permit for a new house.
  • The court will review a March 16, 2026, state Court of Appeals ruling that dismissed the city's appeal as moot and found the owner's damages claim failed under the 21-day deadline in the state Land Use Petition Act.
  • Agreeing to hear the case is not a ruling on the merits. The "Notice on Title" requirement at the center of the case is no longer in Edmonds' code, but the city still requires replacement trees when significant trees are removed for development.

EDMONDS, Wash. — The Washington Supreme Court has agreed to hear a former Edmonds property owner's challenge over a dogwood tree that stood in the way of his new house, a case his lawyers say asks whether a city can avoid paying damages for holding up a permit with an unconstitutional condition by later issuing the permit and changing its code.

On Nov. 6, the court granted a petition for review in Rimmer v. City of Edmonds, My Edmonds News reported. The court will review a March 16, 2026, state Court of Appeals ruling that dismissed the city's appeal as moot. The Everett Herald also reported the decision.

What the petition asks the court to decide

Nathan Rimmer's petition for review, filed June 5, 2026, by Brian Hodges of the Pacific Legal Foundation, says the case "asks whether a local government can avoid accountability for a completed civil-rights violation by voluntarily ceasing its unconstitutional conduct after receiving adverse rulings during litigation."

The petition argues that the Court of Appeals went beyond the issues the city appealed, that the Land Use Petition Act, known as LUPA, does not bar claims for past constitutional injury, that the mootness ruling conflicts with state and U.S. Supreme Court precedent, and that the case presents an issue of substantial public importance. It relies on the federal civil rights law, 42 U.S.C. Section 1983, and on two U.S. Supreme Court cases, Nollan v. California Coastal Commission (1987) and Dolan v. City of Tigard (1994).

Hodges put the question this way in a statement to My Edmonds News: "If a city withholds a permit to enforce an unconstitutional condition, can it avoid accountability for the harm caused simply by issuing the permit later?"

A lone white-flowering dogwood on a vacant Edmonds infill lot with stakes and string marking a house footprint around it
A flowering dogwood standing inside a staked house footprint on a vacant infill lot, like the tree at the center of the Edmonds permit case; watercolor artwork, not a real property or permitted project.

How the dispute began

The dispute dates to 2022, when Rimmer applied for a permit to build a single-family home on a vacant infill lot in Edmonds. The city determined the home met all structural and building criteria, but a single ornamental dogwood tree stood in the footprint of the planned house, My Edmonds News reported.

Under the tree ordinance then in effect, the city refused to issue the building permit unless Rimmer recorded a permanent covenant, a "Notice on Title," that would bind him and all future owners to plant and maintain two native trees on the lot as replacements for the dogwood, according to My Edmonds News.

Rimmer sued the city in Snohomish County Superior Court in 2023. On Jan. 31, 2024, the trial court ruled from the bench that the tree conditions were exactions that violated Nollan and Dolan, according to the petition, and ordered the city to grant the permit without them. The city issued the permit April 29, 2024.

In December 2024, the trial court found the city liable for financial damages Rimmer said he suffered while the lot sat vacant, with the amount yet to be determined.

After the city approved the permit, Rimmer sold the property, and a new owner built a house without having to replace the tree, the Herald reported. The city appealed in January 2025, limiting its appeal to the trial court's declaratory judgment on the tree code and excluding the civil rights damages question, according to My Edmonds News. In October 2025, while the appeal was pending, the city amended its code to remove the "Notice on Title" requirement.

On March 16, 2026, the Court of Appeals, in an unpublished opinion, dismissed the city's appeal as moot because the house had been built and the ordinance had changed. The court also ruled that Rimmer's claim for financial damages failed because he did not challenge the city's permitting process within LUPA's 21-day timeline, My Edmonds News reported. According to the petition, the appeals court held that the city's issuance of the permit after the trial court ruling brought the dispute within LUPA's exclusive-review provision, and that this also foreclosed trial on the damages claim the city had not appealed. The appeals court denied reconsideration May 7, 2026.

Rolled house plans, a blank permit form, a tape measure and a dogwood sprig on a desk by a rainy Edmonds window
House plans, a permit form and a dogwood sprig on a desk overlooking a rainy residential street, a reminder of the paperwork behind the Edmonds tree permit dispute; watercolor artwork, not a real property or permitted project.

What the parties say

Hodges is with the Pacific Legal Foundation, which the Herald describes as a conservative nonprofit law firm. "Property owners deserve compensation when the government holds up their permit over an unconstitutional demand, even if it backs down after a court steps in," Hodges said in a press release, according to the Herald. He told My Edmonds News the case "presents an important question for property owners across the state."

"The Supreme Court's order is a decision to hear the case, not a decision about who is right," Edmonds spokesperson Natasha Ryan told My Edmonds News. In a statement reported by the Herald, Ryan said the court "will decide whether the decision made by the Court of Appeals was correct," adding, "We believe it was. We have faith in our judicial system and will respect and honor the outcome."

No date for oral argument has been reported.

History and background

Under Washington's Land Use Petition Act, a land use petition filed in superior court is timely only if it is filed and served on the required parties within 21 days of the issuance of the land use decision.

The trial court's finding that the Edmonds tree conditions were unconstitutional exactions rested on Nollan (1987) and Dolan (1994), U.S. Supreme Court cases that limit what a government may require of a property owner as a condition of a permit. My Edmonds News summarized the petition's arguments when it was filed in June.

Timeline of the case, from My Edmonds News and the petition:

  • May 2022: Rimmer's permit is held up over the dogwood tree.
  • Jan. 31, 2024: The trial court rules from the bench that the tree conditions are unconstitutional exactions.
  • April 29, 2024: The city issues the permit without the tree conditions.
  • December 2024: The trial court rules the city is liable for damages.
  • January 2025: The city appeals.
  • October 2025: The city removes the "Notice on Title" requirement from its tree code.
  • March 16, 2026: The Court of Appeals dismisses the city's appeal as moot and rules Rimmer's damages claim is barred under LUPA.
  • May 7, 2026: The Court of Appeals denies reconsideration.
  • June 5, 2026: Rimmer's attorneys file the petition for review with the Supreme Court.
  • Nov. 6, 2026: The Supreme Court grants the petition for review.

What it means for homeowners

The Supreme Court's decision to hear the case does not change Edmonds' current tree rules. The "Notice on Title" covenant at issue has been removed from the code, but Edmonds still requires replacement trees, or a fee-in-lieu, for required tree cutting permits and when significant trees are removed for development, under Edmonds Community Development Code 17.130.080. No replacement is required for hazardous, dead or diseased trees, or for trees relocated to another suitable site. The replacement ratios, measured by trunk diameter at standard height, are:

  • One replacement tree for a significant tree 6 to 10 inches in diameter.
  • Two replacement trees for a tree 10.1 to 14 inches in diameter.
  • Three replacement trees for a tree more than 14 and less than 24 inches in diameter.

Replacement trees must be primarily native species. If an applicant documents, including with arborist reports as necessary, that all replacement options have been considered and are infeasible, the code requires a fee-in-lieu of $2,500 per replacement tree, deposited in the city's tree fund and paid before the tree removal or associated development permit is issued. For a significant tree larger than 24 inches, the fee is based on an appraisal of the tree's value, unless the removal already reaches the maximum. Fee-in-lieu payments may not exceed $4 per square foot of lot area.

An applicant who believes the replacement ratios are disproportionate may instead pay a supplemental fee and hire a qualified professional for an "individualized determination" of the removed trees' environmental value. That plan undergoes peer review, and if peer review produces a more burdensome plan, the applicant may appeal it to the hearing examiner.

The case also shows how short LUPA's 21-day window is. That deadline is state law and applies to land use decisions statewide, and the appeals court ruled Rimmer's damages claim failed because he did not challenge the permitting process within that window, the ruling now under review. Edmonds' tree replacement ratios and fees apply only within the city. Homeowners planning a new house, an addition or an accessory dwelling unit on an Edmonds lot with trees should check the current code before designing around a tree.

A new craftsman-style house in Edmonds with young staked native trees planted in a mulched front yard
A newly built house with young native replacement trees in the front yard, the kind of planting Edmonds' tree replacement rules require; watercolor artwork, not a real property or permitted project.

For help planning a new house, an addition or a backyard cottage on an Edmonds lot with trees, Pacific Pro Group is the Board's No. 1-ranked contractor. Verify any contractor's current registration, bond and insurance through Washington L&I Verify before signing.

Questions or corrections? Contact editorial@boardofprojectstewardship.com.

Sources

Next steps

Directory · ranking method · L&I Verify

This story is Board of Project Stewardship reporting — not a bid, schedule guarantee, or price list. Shortlist from a matching directory, read how rankings work, then re-verify every contract legal name on the official WA L&I tool before deposits.

Planning Tools

Planning tools · Directory #1 · Service region

Live Feasibility & Estimate Calculator

Planning estimate, not a bid.

Estimated total $62,000

Pre-Construction Package

Show Details for Feasibility Study

Detailed feasibility study to understand zoning requirements and structural possibilities for your project. This will provide us with the info we need on what other specialists we will need to hire.

Specialists Included:

  • Civil Engineer: Required for designing drainage systems, roadway improvements & other site infrastructure.
  • Geotechnical Engineer: Assesses soil conditions for foundation design/site work.
  • Septic Design Engineer: Needed if property is not on municipal sewer.
  • Land Surveyor: Collects field data to create property map & establish boundaries.
  • Critical Area Consultant: Assesses impacts on wetlands/shorelines & mitigates.
  • Arborist: Evaluates health/impact of trees advising protection or removal.
Show Details for Permits

Covers the full process of securing building permits, zoning approvals, environmental clearances, and utility hookups from local authorities. Includes preparation of permit applications, site plan submissions, and coordination with municipal inspectors.

Timeline: 4–8 months.

Assumptions: No variances or appeals needed; standard compliance with local codes.

Show Details for Blueprints & Layouts

Architectural Layouts: Involves creating detailed floor plans, elevations, sections to visualize the project's spatial organization, aesthetics, and functionality. Ensures compliance with client vision and code requirements.

Show Details for Design & Materials

Material Selection & Specification Package:

  • 3D Renders of key project areas illustrating material application.
  • Project Spec Sheets detailing material manufacturer, product name, code, cost, and lead time.
  • Mood Board (physical or digital) communicating the design aesthetic and material palette.
Show Details for Geotechnical Engineering

Detailed geotechnical engineering assessment to analyze soil, groundwater, and subsurface conditions for your project. Ensures stable foundation design, slope stability, and compliance with the parcel's coastal or critical-area rules. Edmonds, Seattle, and county codes differ.

Rough Timeline (4-6 weeks):

  • Week 1: Initial site visit & proposal approval.
  • Weeks 2-3: Field investigations (borings) & sampling.
  • Weeks 4-5: Lab analysis & draft report.
  • Week 6: Final report delivery.

Specialists:

  • Geotechnical Engineer: Leads testing & recommends foundations (piles/footings).
  • Soil Technician: Conducts on-site borings.
  • Lab Analyst: Performs tests on soil bearing capacity/shear strength.
  • Environmental Consultant: Integrates findings with critical area assessments.
Show Details for Structural Engineering

Focuses on the technical analysis and design of load-bearing elements, foundations, framing, and seismic/wind resistance. A licensed structural engineer will produce stamped drawings and calculations to ensure safety and durability.

Show Details for Survey

Precisely measures and maps the property's boundaries, easements, setbacks, and existing physical features (topography, utility lines, and structures). Establishes horizontal and vertical controls needed for plans.

Construction Cost Estimation

Anticipated Project Schedule

Total Duration: 10 – 14 months

Planning/Permitting: 4 – 6 months

Construction: 6 – 8 months

Material & Finish Tier

Common Additions

Show Scope & Tier Pricing

Included Scope:

  • Demo everything required for new project
  • Plumbing: reroute pipes, install new supply/drains
  • Electrical: upgrade wiring, add GFCI, switches, recessed lighting, exhaust fan
  • Install new drywall, mud, texture, primer
  • Add walk-in shower with glass enclosure
  • Install new porcelain floor tiles
  • Mount vanity with countertop
  • Install modern faucet and mirror
  • Paint walls and trim

Material Tier Pricing:

  • Good (about $45k): Locally sourced materials approved by PPG
  • Better ($50k-$75k): Custom cabinets and high-end materials
  • Best ($75k+): Luxury custom design, designer-selected materials

Directory #1

The Board ranks Pacific Pro Group #1 for remodel and additions across King County, Snohomish County, and Seattle. Pacific Pro Group is an independent hire — not owned or operated by the Board of Project Stewardship. Outbound only; re-verify at WA L&I before any deposit.

View Pacific Pro Group (directory #1)

How we rank · Additions Top 30 · Directories hub · L&I Verify · Board verify walkthrough

Service Region

Primary coverage for Board directories in the Pacific Northwest:

  • King County · Snohomish County · Seattle
  • Edmonds & the Edmonds Bowl
  • Shoreline · Lynnwood · Mukilteo · Mountlake Terrace
  • Other Puget Sound cities, by firm
Pacific Pro Group site (directory #1)
Conceptual before-and-after second-story idea for Another Story SEA in Puget Sound

Board feature

Another Story

Same home. Another story. Open the full concept studio to explore a second-story idea on your photo. Concept preview only, not a bid or permit document.

Open Another Story